Sunday, December 2, 2007

Does diversity matter?

It's been a tradition for the Iowa caucuses to kick off the presidential nomination process. A lot of what happens in Iowa can help to influence the rest of the state's votes, contributing to candidates' momentum throughout the primaries. Yesterday, Democratic candidates met in Des Moines to discuss diversity. Immigration policy, the disproportionate amount of minorities incarcerated, college costs, and Cuban relations were brought up.
It's not a coincidence that Iowa was chosen because there has been much talk about the lack of diversity within the caucuses there. The question came up: Are caucuses with only 8% minorities representing the U.S.? This is less than a third of the country's non-whites. The answer is obviously no, but does should caucuses like these really have so much influence in the beginning of the presidential primaries? Do they have a lot of influence in the election, or is Iowa's influence on the election exaggerated? Should another, more diverse, state be the first primary held? Is it racist in itself to even question diversity?
For anyone who read Hardball, you'll remember how Matthews talked about the advantage of winning early primaries being that the nominee will have their image improved and influence other states' votes. Iowa's caucuses will be held on January 3rd for both the Democrats and Republicans.
Here's a link to the Wall Street Journal article on Saturday's meeting: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB119660870919510917.html?mod=googlenews_wsj

2 comments:

Ryan Landis said...

I think winning the caucus is important but it is played up way to much by the media. In reality if the media did not cover Iowa like is was the "win all" state, then the candidate's image would get a boost, but any reasonable voter would not allow this to change their opinion. Also, can it be stated that Iowa is predominately white state, almost 95% of its citizens being so.

Thanks to Wikipedia, 8% minority representation seems like their true share!

Demographics of Iowa (csv)
By race
White Black AIAN Asian

2000 (total population) 96.14% 2.51% 0.63% 1.48%

Ryan Landis said...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iowa#Demographics

Here is the sight where the best things happen!

I owe ya DJ Cheeves